Payday loans vs instalment loans

Last reviewed Reviewed by Editorial team, Loans Canada OnlineHow we research

A payday loan is up to $1,500, due within 62 days, and costs up to $14 per $100. An instalment loan is usually larger, repaid in regular payments over months or years, and capped at a 35% annual rate. For anything beyond a brief gap, an instalment loan usually costs less overall.

What is the difference?

Payday loan Instalment (personal) loan
Amount Up to $1,500 Often $500 to $50,000
Term Up to 62 days Months to years
Repayment Usually one payment (instalments in Alberta) Fixed regular payments
Cost limit $14 per $100 borrowed 35% APR criminal rate limit
Typical approval Income and bank account focus Credit and income review

Which costs less?

For the same amount and time, an instalment loan almost always costs less. Borrowing $1,000 for two months as a payday loan costs up to $140. A $1,000 instalment loan at 30% APR repaid in two monthly payments costs roughly $38 in interest.

The picture changes if you stretch an instalment loan over years: a lower rate on a bigger balance for longer can add up to more total interest. Always compare the total cost in dollars.

When might a payday loan make sense?

When the amount is small, the gap is short and one-time, you are confident you can repay in full on the due date, and cheaper options are not available. Even then, use the calculator to see the total first.

When is an instalment loan the better fit?

When you need more than a few hundred dollars, when repaying everything from one paycheque would leave you short, or when you are consolidating other debts. Loans Canada Online can match personal-loan enquiries with partners — start an enquiry — but we are not a lender and do not make lending decisions.

What should I watch for with high-cost instalment loans?

Some instalment lenders charge close to the 35% limit and add optional insurance or membership fees. Ask for the total cost of borrowing, decline add-ons you do not want, and check whether your province requires a high-cost credit licence — Alberta does, for example.

Frequently asked questions

What is the maximum interest on an instalment loan in Canada?

Since January 1, 2025, the criminal interest rate is 35% APR. Most consumer instalment loans must stay at or below that limit.

Is a longer loan always cheaper?

Not always. A lower rate over a longer term can still cost more in total interest. Compare the total cost of borrowing in dollars, not just the rate.

Loans Canada Online is not a lender and does not make lending decisions. Loan terms, rates, fees, approval and availability are set by each licensed lender and depend on your province. Payday-loan rules differ by province — verify a lender’s licence with your provincial regulator before borrowing.

Calculate cost Get Started Now
Add up to 4 lenders to compare
Compare